Home runs allowed are a park and luck stat
Few things damage a pitcher’s reputation faster than the long ball. A starter who gives up a lot of home runs gets labeled homer-prone, his fastball is described as too straight, and his manager is second-guessed for leaving him in. Home runs allowed feel like one of the most direct measures of a pitcher’s failure: he threw a pitch, and the hitter sent it over the fence. But over a single season, the home run count is shaped heavily by things the pitcher does not control, chiefly the ballpark he pitches in, the weather, and the large element of chance in whether a fly ball carries a few extra feet.
Home runs are rare, which makes them noisy
A full-time starting pitcher faces several hundred batters a season, but he gives up only a couple of dozen home runs or so. Any event that rare is subject to big random swings. A handful of fly balls that land on the warning track one year and in the bleachers the next can move a pitcher’s home run rate dramatically, and his earned run average with it, since a home run is the most damaging single outcome a pitcher can allow.
This is why analysts have long separated home runs from the other parts of a pitcher’s line. Strikeouts and walks are fairly stable from year to year; a pitcher who strikes out a lot of hitters this season will probably do it again next season. Home run rate is much less stable. A pitcher who led the league in home runs allowed one year often looks ordinary the next without any obvious change in how he pitches.
Fly balls are a skill. Fly balls leaving the park, less so.
A useful way to break down home runs is into two pieces: how many fly balls a pitcher allows, and what share of those fly balls clear the fence. The first piece is largely a pitcher skill. Pitchers who work up in the zone with rising fastballs tend to give up more fly balls, while sinkerball pitchers keep the ball on the ground. That tendency persists across seasons.
The second piece, the home-run-to-fly-ball rate, is much noisier for pitchers. Over large samples, most pitchers cluster fairly close to the league average, with luck and park explaining a big share of the year-to-year variation. That observation is the basis for xFIP, a version of fielding independent pitching that replaces a pitcher’s actual home runs with the number he would have allowed at a league-average home-run-per-fly-ball rate. It treats the fly balls as the pitcher’s responsibility and the share that leaves the park as mostly out of his hands.
That is a simplification. Some pitchers do appear to suppress hard contact on fly balls better than others, and some give up an unusual number of loud fly balls because their pitches are easy to square up. Statcast data on exit velocity and launch angle has helped separate pitchers who truly allow dangerous contact from those who were simply unlucky. But for a single season, an extreme home-run-to-fly-ball rate is more likely to regress toward average than to repeat.
The ballpark moves the fence
Baseball is unusual among major sports in that its playing fields are not the same size. Outfield fences sit at different distances and heights, and some parks have short porches down one line that turn routine fly balls into home runs. Altitude matters too. The thinner air in Denver lets batted balls travel farther, which is why Coors Field has long been the most hitter-friendly park in the majors. Other parks, with deep alleys or heavy marine air, suppress home runs.
A pitcher makes roughly half his starts at home, so his home park has an outsized effect on his season totals. A fly-ball pitcher in a park that inflates home runs will allow more of them than the same pitcher would in a park that suppresses them. Park factors, which compare how often home runs are hit in a given ballpark relative to the league, are an essential adjustment before comparing pitchers on different teams. A home run total without the context of the park is only half the story.
Weather and the ball itself
Conditions on a given day matter as well. Warm air is less dense than cold air, so batted balls carry farther in summer than in April or September. Wind blowing out can turn a routine fly ball into a home run; wind blowing in can knock down a ball that would otherwise have cleared the fence. A pitcher whose starts happen to fall on hot, windy days in a hitter-friendly park can see his home run total inflated by conditions he had nothing to do with.
Then there is the baseball. League-wide home run rates have swung noticeably over the past decade, and changes in the ball’s construction and drag have been widely discussed as one reason. When the whole league’s home run rate rises or falls, every pitcher’s numbers shift with it. Comparing a pitcher’s home run totals across seasons without accounting for the league-wide environment can make a pitcher look better or worse than he is.
Sequencing magnifies the damage
Not every home run costs the same. A solo shot with nobody on base costs one run. The same swing with the bases loaded costs four. Whether a home run comes with runners aboard depends partly on how many hitters the pitcher let reach before it, but it also depends on timing that is hard to control. Two pitchers can allow the same number of home runs and see very different earned run averages because one gave up mostly solo shots and the other gave up a few with traffic on the bases. That sequencing tends to even out over time, which is another reason ERA swings so much from season to season.
A better way to judge the long ball
Home runs allowed are not meaningless. A pitcher who gives up a lot of hard-hit fly balls has a real problem, and some pitchers do struggle with the long ball year after year. But a single season’s home run count needs context before it supports a verdict:
- Fly-ball rate: is the pitcher allowing more fly balls than average, which is a persistent tendency?
- Home runs per fly ball: is that rate far above league average, which is likely to regress?
- Quality of contact: are the fly balls being hit hard, or did softer contact sneak over the fence?
- Home park: does he pitch half his games in a park that inflates or suppresses home runs?
- League environment: was it a high or low home run season across baseball?
A pitcher with an elevated home run total, an ordinary fly-ball rate, average contact quality, and a hitter-friendly home park is a strong candidate to look much better next year. A pitcher who allows a lot of hard fly balls everywhere he goes is the one who is genuinely homer-prone.
The pitcher decides whether the ball goes in the air. The park, the weather, and a few feet of luck often decide whether it comes down.