The Most Improved Player award is a minutes award
Every spring the Most Improved Player race produces the same kind of winner. A player who averaged eleven points last season averages twenty this season, the jump looks enormous on a stat page, and voters reward it. The story told about that player is a story of growth: a summer in the gym, a new move, more confidence. Sometimes that story is true. But the number that usually drives the vote is not a measure of improvement at all. It is a per-game scoring average, and per-game averages move most when a player’s role changes. More often than not, the Most Improved Player is the most promoted player.
Per-game averages are minutes multiplied by everything else
A points-per-game figure is the product of two things: how many minutes a player is on the floor, and how much he produces in each of those minutes. Improvement, in the sense most fans mean it, lives in the second term. A player who gets better at shooting, finishing, or creating should score more per minute. The first term, playing time, is a coaching decision.
When a player goes from twenty-two minutes a night to thirty-four, his scoring average rises by more than half even if he is exactly the same player he was. Nothing about his skill changed. His coach simply put him on the court longer. Yet that jump, on a per-game basis, looks identical to the jump a player would show if he had genuinely transformed his game. The award’s voters see the same column either way.
The simplest correction is to look at production per 36 minutes or per 100 possessions alongside the per-game line. When a candidate’s per-minute numbers barely move while his per-game numbers soar, the case is mostly about opportunity. When the per-minute numbers rise too, there is real evidence of a better player.
Usage is a second opportunity stat
Minutes are not the only lever. Within those minutes, a player can be handed a larger share of the offense. A wing who spent last season standing in the corner while a star ran the show may find himself running pick-and-rolls after that star is traded or injured. His usage rate, the share of team possessions that end with his shot, free throws, or turnover, climbs sharply, and his scoring follows.
That is still not improvement in the strict sense. A player taking more shots will score more points almost by definition. The real question is whether he stays efficient with the bigger load. Players who absorb a large usage increase while holding their true shooting percentage steady have done something difficult, because efficiency usually falls as shot volume rises. Players whose efficiency collapses as their volume climbs have mainly been given more chances to miss. Both can post an identical points-per-game leap.
Where the opportunity comes from
It helps to ask why the minutes and touches appeared. The common sources are easy to spot once you look for them:
- A teammate left. A star departs in free agency or a trade, and his shots have to go somewhere.
- A teammate got hurt. An injury to a starter opens a long stretch of extra minutes, sometimes for most of a season.
- A new coach arrived. A different staff may simply trust a player the previous one did not.
- The team stopped trying to win. Rebuilding teams hand big roles to young players to see what they have, and losing teams have little reason to protect a lead with veterans.
- The player changed teams. A backup on a deep contender can become a starter on a thin roster without changing anything about his game.
None of these is a reason to dismiss a candidate. Players still have to do something with the chance. But each one explains part of a jump that the per-game numbers attribute entirely to the player.
Last season might have been the outlier
There is a quieter problem too. Improvement is measured against the previous season, and the previous season is not always a fair baseline. A player who missed months with an injury, played through a nagging ailment, or shot unusually poorly from three over a modest sample may simply be returning to his normal level. Going from a down year back to an ordinary one looks like growth on a year-over-year chart.
Three-point shooting is the clearest example. A few hundred attempts is not a large sample, and a player’s percentage can swing several points from one season to the next on luck alone. A guard who shoots thirty-one percent from deep one year and thirty-seven the next may have improved his mechanics, or he may have had one cold year and one warm one. Free-throw percentage, which stabilizes faster and reflects the same shooting stroke, is a useful check. If a player’s free-throw percentage also climbed, the three-point gain is more believable.
What the award rewards in practice
Put those pieces together and a pattern emerges. The candidates who rise to the top of the ballot are usually players who gained both minutes and usage in the same season, often because of a roster change, and who arrive with a big per-game scoring increase. That profile fits the stat page perfectly. It does not necessarily fit the idea of a player who got better.
Meanwhile, some kinds of genuine improvement barely register. A center who becomes a far better defender, a guard who cuts his turnovers sharply, or a role player who adds a reliable corner three may change his team’s results without changing his scoring average much. Those players rarely win, because the award is mostly discussed in points per game.
A better way to read a candidate
None of this requires throwing out the award. It just means reading a Most Improved Player case with a few extra questions:
- Did his production per 36 minutes or per 100 possessions rise, or only his per-game totals?
- Did his efficiency hold up as his usage increased?
- Did his playing time or role change because of something outside his control?
- Was the previous season a fair baseline, or a down year?
- Did the parts of his game that do not show up in scoring get better too?
A player who passes those tests has a real claim to having improved. A player who only shows a per-game jump has mostly shown that someone gave him the ball. That can be worth celebrating, since plenty of players get a chance and do nothing with it, but it is a different achievement than the one the award’s name describes.
The award asks who got better. The stat page answers a different question: who got more.